Independent information and referral site. Not a utility, contractor or government agency. Figures link to their sources. How we make money
California solar decisions
NEM 2.0 vs NEM 3.0 California: What Changed and What It Means For You
California's solar billing tariff changed from NEM 2.0 to NEM 3.0 (officially the Net Billing Tariff) in April 2023. If you installed solar before April 15, 2023, you're grandfathered onto NEM 2.0 for 20 years; after that date, you're on NEM 3.0. The two differ mainly in export compensation, which is what this page compares side by side.
California Rate Relief is a private solar referral service.
What the two tariff names describe
The CPUC describes NEM as a program in which a participating customer receives bill credits for excess generation exported to the grid. Its current Net Billing Tariff, also called the Solar Billing Plan or NEM 3.0, applies to new interconnection applicants in the large investor-owned utility territories beginning April 15, 2023.
Under both structures, generation used in the home first reduces electricity bought from the grid. The key billing difference is how exported generation is credited. The CPUC says Net Billing export compensation usually differs from the retail rate and can vary by time; the account's current utility documents control the actual calculation. Why midday exports earn so little and evening exports so much comes down to the grid pattern known as the duck curve behind net billing.
What is NEM 2.0 in California?
NEM 2.0 (written NEM2 on PG&E paperwork, and sometimes mistyped as “NMEC 2.0”) is California's second net energy metering tariff for rooftop solar. The CPUC created it in 2016 under Assembly Bill 327, in Decision D.16-01-044, to replace the original NEM 1.0. It applied to PG&E, SCE and SDG&E customers who applied to interconnect from their utility's NEM 1.0 sunset in 2016 or 2017 until April 14, 2023.
Under NEM 2.0, solar you export is credited at the same retail price you pay for power in that hour, including generation, distribution and transmission. The CPUC added three conditions NEM 1.0 did not have:
- A one-time interconnection fee for systems up to 1 MW: $145 at PG&E, $94 at SCE and $132 at SDG&E.
- Non-bypassable charges, small per-kWh charges for public programs, paid on the net energy you draw from the grid in each hour instead of once a year.
- A time-of-use rate. Any of the utility's TOU plans qualifies; NEM 2.0 does not tie you to one plan.
Billing is annual: charges and credits roll forward for 12 months and are settled at the true-up. If you exported more than you used over the year, the surplus is paid at the net surplus compensation rate, which the CPUC puts at roughly 2 to 3 cents per kWh. PG&E's rate for true-up months in 2025 ranged from 2.919 to 3.396 cents.
The side-by-side: NEM 2.0 vs. NEM 3.0
Both tariffs work the same basic way — your solar offsets what you use first, and only the leftover gets exported — but they price that leftover, and the years you're locked into a plan, differently.
| NEM 2.0 | NEM 3.0 (Net Billing Tariff) | |
|---|---|---|
| Export compensation basis | Bill credits at the full retail rate — generation, distribution and transmission components together, per the CPUC | Credits from the CPUC's Avoided Cost Calculator (ACC), a value “usually lower than the retail rate” that varies by time of day, day of week and season, per the CPUC and PG&E |
| Time-of-use requirement | Must take service on a time-of-use rate — any qualifying TOU plan, per the CPUC | Must take service on “a specific TOU rate” with a steeper on-peak/off-peak spread than other TOU rates, per the CPUC (PG&E auto-enrolls residential NEM 3.0 customers on Electric Home, E-ELEC) |
| Grandfathering / legacy period | 20 years from your interconnection date, under D.14-03-041, per the CPUC | No 20-year legacy period. The original customer is “guaranteed the use of the NBT tariff for nine years,” per the CPUC |
| What ends it early | Expanding the system past your utility's threshold moves the account onto NEM 3.0 before the 20 years is up — PG&E's is more than 10% of the original nameplate capacity or more than 1 kW, per PG&E. Full utility-by-utility thresholds: What is NEM 3.0 in California? | The nine-year tariff lock is the floor. PG&E and SCE (not SDG&E) customers who interconnect an NEM 3.0 system before the end of 2027 also get nine years of enhanced export credits on top of that, per the CPUC |
| True-up billing cadence | Annual billing — both charges and credits roll over for the full 12 months, per the CPUC | Monthly billing — you're billed or credited every month, and only unresolved solar credits carry forward to the annual true-up, per the CPUC. See how the annual true-up is settled for what that looks like utility by utility |
| Battery economics | Exporting paid close to what you'd otherwise pay to buy the power back, so storing it yourself added little financial upside | Exporting now pays less than buying power back at your TOU rate, so using stored solar in the evening is the main lever NEM 3.0 gives homeowners to control the bill — nearly 70% of NEM 3.0 (NBT) customers had paired a battery with solar by the end of 2024, per the CPUC. See battery payback under NEM 3.0 for the utility-by-utility math |
NEM 1.0 vs. NEM 2.0 vs. NEM 3.0: all three
The CPUC created NEM 1.0 in 1996 under Senate Bill 656, and systems joined it until the 2016–2017 sunset dates. NEM 2.0 followed in 2016, and the Net Billing Tariff (NEM 3.0) has applied to new applications since April 15, 2023. This is how the CPUC compares them:
| NEM 1.0 | NEM 2.0 | NEM 3.0 (NBT) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Required rate plan | Any | Any time-of-use rate | A specific electrification TOU rate (E-ELEC, TOU-D-PRIME or EV-TOU-5) |
| Credit for exports before true-up | Import (retail) rates | Import (retail) rates | Avoided Cost Calculator values, usually lower than retail rates |
| Surplus at true-up | Wholesale price | Wholesale price | Wholesale price |
| Non-bypassable charges on | Net energy used over the year | Net energy used in each hour | All energy imported |
| Interconnection fee | None | $94–$145 | $94–$145 |
| Billing | Annual billing and true-up | Annual billing and true-up | Pay monthly; credits roll over to an annual true-up |
| System size limit | Annual load, capped at 1 MW | Annual load | Annual load plus up to 50% if you attest to the need |
Source: CPUC, Net Energy Metering and Net Billing, comparison of standard NEM tariffs and NBT, checked September 23, 2026. Applies to PG&E, SCE and SDG&E.
When does NEM 2.0 expire?
Twenty years after your system's interconnection date, under CPUC Decision D.14-03-041, unless you choose to switch to the current tariff sooner. A system interconnected in 2020 keeps NEM 2.0 until 2040. The clock follows the system's interconnection date, not the date you bought the house. PG&E states the same 20-year period for its NEM 1.0 customers.
The door to new NEM 2.0 accounts is shut. PG&E says applications submitted before April 15, 2023 had to be completed by April 15, 2026 to keep NEM2; from that date, unfinished NEM2 applications move to the Solar Billing Plan.
Municipal utilities and non-export systems
NEM 2.0 and NEM 3.0 are CPUC tariffs for PG&E, SCE and SDG&E. City-owned utilities write their own. LADWP still uses net energy metering: its NEM rider credits exported energy at your rate schedule's energy price and carries credits forward, but zeroes any balance left when you close the account. SMUD moved new solar customers to its Solar and Storage Rate on March 1, 2022, which pays 9.6 cents per kWh for exports at any hour, and lets its NEM 1.0 customers stay on that rate through 2030. See LADWP net metering and the SMUD solar program for the details.
A non-export system is a third path. PG&E's Rule 21 defines it as a system sized and designed so its output serves only the home and cannot flow onto the grid. It takes no NEM or net billing credits because it sends nothing out, but it still has to be interconnected under the utility's Rule 21 process. The CPUC's net metering page expressly leaves non-export interconnection out of scope.
Who should check the existing NEM tariff
The CPUC states that NEM 2.0 customers may remain on that tariff for 20 years from interconnection, unless they choose to switch to the current tariff. A homeowner should confirm the interconnection date, tariff and any proposed system change directly with the utility before treating a proposal as a continuation of the prior arrangement.
Three changes cause most of the questions. Adding panels past your utility's threshold moves the account to NEM 3.0 (see adding solar panels to an existing system). Selling the home does not restart the 20-year clock, which runs from the interconnection date, and a lease or PPA contract is a separate matter (see selling a home with a solar lease or PPA and solar PPA vs. lease). And the rate plan you pick still decides what each exported kWh earns under NEM 2.0, since credits follow the hour's retail price; PG&E's plans are listed in PG&E rate schedules.
What a comparable proposal needs to show
Ask every bidder to identify the utility, tariff, assumed onsite use, projected imports, projected exports, remaining delivery and fixed charges, and the source date for each assumption. A single estimated monthly payment does not show those inputs.
Put the quotes on the same basis
A smaller monthly payment can hide a longer contract, less equipment or a larger remaining electric bill. Ask each bidder to fill the same gaps.
| Compare | Get it in writing |
|---|---|
| System and output | Same DC system size, module/inverter models and roof layout; monthly production with shading and losses shown. |
| Battery and backup | Usable kWh, continuous output, backed-up circuits, reserve setting and expected replacement costs. |
| Price and scope | Separate solar, battery, roof, panel upgrade, permits and interconnection. Compare cash prices before financing. |
| Utility bill | Same usage history and tariff; separate onsite use, grid imports, export credits and remaining fixed/delivery charges. |
| Contract and service | Who installs and who services it; written coverage by address, insurance, license record, exclusions and warranty claim process. |
| Payment and transfer | Cash, loan, lease or PPA; upfront costs, APR or escalator, total payments, home-sale and end-of-term terms. |
Use the current bill before relying on a comparison
This guide applies to PG&E, SCE and SDG&E Net Billing context. A municipal or community-choice account can have additional service and billing details. Read the current bill and utility enrollment before comparing it to a generic example. For the official consumer checklist, see the CPUC guide.
What the tariff change does to a battery and a true-up
The table above covers both at a glance: NEM 3.0's lower, hourly export credit is what makes self-consuming stored solar worth more than exporting it, and its true-up runs on a monthly billing cycle instead of NEM 2.0's fully annual one. For the two specific questions this raises:
Frequently asked questions
What is NEM 2.0 in California?
NEM 2.0 is California's second net energy metering tariff for rooftop solar at PG&E, SCE and SDG&E, created by the CPUC in 2016 (Decision D.16-01-044). It credits exported solar at the retail price of the hour, requires a time-of-use rate, charges a one-time interconnection fee ($145 at PG&E, $94 at SCE, $132 at SDG&E) and collects non-bypassable charges on net usage in each hour. It closed to new applicants on April 14, 2023.
What's the actual difference between NEM 2.0 and NEM 3.0 in California?
Mainly export compensation. NEM 2.0 credits exported solar at the retail rate; NEM 3.0 (the Net Billing Tariff) credits it using the CPUC's Avoided Cost Calculator, which is usually lower and changes by hour. NEM 3.0 also replaces the 20-year legacy period with a nine-year tariff guarantee, requires a specific electrification rate plan, and bills monthly instead of annually.
What is the difference between NEM 1.0, NEM 2.0 and NEM 3.0?
NEM 1.0 (1996 to the 2016-2017 sunsets) credited exports at retail with no interconnection fee and any rate plan. NEM 2.0 (2016 to April 14, 2023) kept retail credits but added a $94 to $145 fee, hourly non-bypassable charges and a time-of-use requirement. NEM 3.0 (applications from April 15, 2023) credits exports at avoided-cost values and bills monthly. NEM 1.0 and 2.0 accounts keep their tariff for 20 years from interconnection.
When does NEM 2.0 expire?
Twenty years from the date your system was interconnected, under CPUC Decision D.14-03-041, unless you switch to the current tariff sooner. A system interconnected in 2020 keeps NEM 2.0 until 2040. Adding capacity past your utility's threshold can end it early.
Is NEM 2.0 better than NEM 3.0?
For export credits alone, NEM 2.0 pays more per kilowatt-hour sent to the grid. Whether that makes NEM 2.0 better for your household depends on how much you export versus use yourself, and whether a battery is in the picture; NEM 3.0's economics improve when you can shift usage to match your own solar output. Neither this page nor the CPUC states a single answer that applies to every home.
When did NEM 3.0 take effect in California?
The CPUC adopted the Net Billing Tariff in Decision D.22-12-056 in December 2022, and it has applied to PG&E, SCE and SDG&E customers who applied to interconnect on or after April 15, 2023. There is no later start date; April 15, 2023 is the date that decides whether a system is on NEM 2.0 or NEM 3.0.
How are export credits calculated under NEM 3.0?
Each hour's exports are credited at a value from the CPUC's Avoided Cost Calculator, which the utilities call Energy Export Credits. The CPUC says the value is usually lower than the retail rate but can rise above it on late summer evenings. Residential PG&E and SCE customers who apply before the end of 2027 get a small adder for nine years; SDG&E customers are excluded.
Does NEM 3.0 apply to LADWP?
No. The Net Billing Tariff covers PG&E, SCE and SDG&E. LADWP is a city-owned utility with its own net energy metering rider, which credits exports at your rate schedule's energy price and carries credits forward, but zeroes any credit balance when you close the account. SMUD also sets its own solar rate.
What does NEM mean on a PG&E bill?
NEM stands for Net Energy Metering, PG&E's program for customers with their own solar. A NEM account gets a monthly statement showing that month's charges, including the Base Services Charge, and a running total of solar charges and credits, then an annual True-Up statement after 12 months that settles the net amount.
What is a non-export solar system in California?
A system sized and designed so its output serves only the home and cannot flow onto the utility grid, as PG&E's Rule 21 defines it. Because nothing is exported, it earns no net metering or net billing credits, but it still has to be interconnected through the utility's Rule 21 process.
I have PG&E NEM 2.0 ("PGE NEM2"). What happens if I add panels or a battery?
Adding capacity can move your account onto NEM 3.0 before your 20 years are up if it crosses PG&E's threshold: more than 10% of your original system's nameplate capacity, or more than 1 kW, per PG&E. Check the threshold with PG&E before signing an expansion contract.
Does a battery pay back differently under NEM 2.0 vs. NEM 3.0?
Under NEM 2.0, exporting paid close to retail value, so a battery's main draw was backup power, not bill savings. Under NEM 3.0, exporting pays less than buying the same power back, so a battery that shifts your usage to your own solar has a real bill-savings case, but the size of that case depends on your utility and usage.
Does this change if my solar is leased or under a PPA (like Sunrun)?
The tariff (NEM 2.0 vs. NEM 3.0) is tied to the system's interconnection date, not who owns it. What a leased or PPA system's export credits mean for your bill, and what happens on a sale, is a contract question with your leaseholder, separate from the utility tariff.
Have your bill reviewed
Start with the utility on your bill and what you pay in a typical month. Contact details come after that. The calculators and checklists on this page stay usable without submitting anything.
California Rate Relief is a referral service. We are not a licensed contractor. California Rate Relief is compensated by a solar provider when a homeowner we refer signs an agreement. How we make money
Before you send anything
- What this is
- California Rate Relief is a private referral service. It is not a contractor, does not install or finance anything, and is not a utility, a government agency or an assistance program.
- What happens after the form
- Your project details are recorded for referral to a solar provider. The provider decides whether it can help and what it can offer; availability, design and price are determined after its own review.
- How you are contacted
- Read the consent wording before submitting. Your inquiry includes contact details for follow-up about the project; a provider decides whether it can serve it.
- Using the site without submitting
- The calculators, bill comparisons and checklists on this site work without contact details, and nothing on this page requires a submission.